Articles tagged "Arbitration"

1 article

Game Theory and Real Estate Practice in 'Baseball' Arbitration
PDF

Game Theory and Real Estate Practice in 'Baseball' Arbitration

Abstract. Final Offer Arbitration, commonly employed in real estate contracts, has been widely studied but primarily in the area of labor disputes. This paper applies the game theoretical models developed in the literature, particularly the work of Brams and Merrill, to the area of real estate, and reviews the results of an experiment in rent determination conducted with real estate professionals. The results of the experiment show consistently sub-optimal behavior by the bidders, which the paper attempts to explicate through ideas developed in the areas of utility theory and mean-variance analysis. The author provides some conclusions designed to assist practitioners.

The paper restates the Brams and Merrill equilibrium for a normally distributed arbitrator, reports a mock rent-arbitration experiment across four markets (201 submissions), fits an exponential utility function to recover the level of risk aversion implied by the observed under-bidding, and derives the variance of the Brams and Merrill payoff. The mean-variance result shows that, for the maximizing party, bids between the arbitrator’s expected position and the Brams and Merrill optimum form an efficient set that dominates every more aggressive bid.

Working paper, first version May 5, 2008. Suggested citation: Colacino, Michael. “Final Offer Arbitration, Game Theory, and Real Estate.” Working paper, 2008.

game theoryarbitrationreal estate